December 7, 2022

Hicks Thomas Attorneys Featured in The Houston Lawyer Magazine Analysis of Texas Supreme Court’s Opinion Recognizing Exceptions to the Eight-Corners Rule

By Hicks Thomas LLP


The Houston Lawyer magazine has published an article by Hicks Thomas partners Courtney Ervin and J. Stephen Barrick and associate Stacie Osborn exploring the Texas Supreme Court’s opinion recognizing exceptions to the eight-corners rule. The article, Monroe Guaranty v. BITCO: Texas Supreme Court (Finally) Recognizes Exceptions to the Eight-Corners Rule,” details the decision that allows courts to consider extrinsic evidence when evaluating whether an insurer has a duty to defend.

In the article, Ms. Ervin, Mr. Barrick, and Ms. Osborn explore the eight-corners rule, which is an analytical tool that Texas courts use to evaluate whether a liability insurer has a duty to defend it’s insured against a claim or lawsuit. Under the rule, an insurer’s duty to defend is determined solely on the allegations in the underlying pleading and the terms of the insurance policy, without considering any “extrinsic” evidence relating to coverage.

Ms. Ervin, Mr. Barrick, and Ms. Osborn write that for years, the Texas Supreme Court has refused to address whether there are exceptions to the eight-corners rule, but that changed in February 2022, when the court issued its opinion in Monroe Guaranty Insurance Company v. BITCO General Insurance Corporation, No. 21-0232. It held that extrinsic evidence can be considered in evaluating whether an insurer has a duty to defend if the extrinsic evidence “(1) goes solely to the issue of coverage and does not overlap with the merits of liability, (2) does not contradict facts alleged in the pleading, and (3) conclusively establishes the coverage fact to be proved.”

“While BITCO’s modification to Northfield appears minimal,” they write, “there will be an uptick in lawsuits as policyholders and insurers alike seek to understand the outer limits of this exception to the eight-corners rule.”

To read the full article, click here.

Related Posts

US News – Best Lawyers Name Hicks Thomas to Best Law Firms List for 2019

HOUSTON – Hicks Thomas LLP earned top-tier honors on the list of Best Law Firms for 2019 by U.S. News & World Report and The Best Lawyers in America, ranked for its exceptional commercial litigation and oil and gas law expertise. The firm achieved Tier 1 rankings both nationally and in the Houston metro…

Full Text

Another Record Recognition: In a Firm First, Ten Hicks Thomas Lawyers Named to List of Texas Super Lawyers

Another Record Recognition: In a Firm First, Ten Hicks Thomas Lawyers Named to List of Texas Super Lawyers Attorneys recognized as best in Texas for business litigation and appellate work HOUSTON – Hicks Thomas is pleased to announce that a firm record of 10 of its lawyers have been named to the…

Full Text

Chambers USA Names Hicks Thomas & Partner Robin Harrison Among Best in Texas Commercial Litigation

HOUSTON – Hicks Thomas LLP has again been named one of the top commercial litigation firms in Texas by the prestigious 2020 Chambers USA guide released April 24.  Hicks Thomas Partner Robin L. Harrison also again earned individual recognition in the guide for his commercial litigation expertise. The Chambers USA guide is one of…

Full Text

Call: 713-547-9100